2018-11-05 DOE Modeling PI Meeting + E3SM 11-09

Where

Bolger Center, Potomac, MD

When

Nov 5-8 - DOE Modeling PI Meeting

Nov 9, half day – E3SM All-Hands Meeting

What

The meeting will include investigators from across the DOE Laboratory modeling programs (ESM, RGCM and IAR). It is the joint meeting of the three major modeling communities within the new Earth and Environmental Systems Modeling: Earth System Modeling (Model Development), Regional and Global Model Analysis (Model Analysis), and Multi-Sector Dynamics.

The meeting has been constructed and partitioned around two main objectives. First, and with the primary objective of strengthening connections among the three main communities, Days 1-2 will emphasize cross-community information exchange as well as collaborative brainstorming and working sessions on a range of cross-cutting themes. One of several desired outcomes should be the development of candidate cross-community research topics or collaborative science use cases. During the second part of the meeting, Days 3-4 will provide each of the three main communities an opportunity to meet separately and conduct work on a range of issues and topics central to their unique science needs and methodological challenges. To the degree possible, coordinated scheduling for the last two days will seek to enable those individuals engaged in research for more than one of the three main communities to attend the required sessions. Finally, efforts are underway to provide ad hoc meeting space for working teams on the fifth day, Friday, but a final determination of availability is in the process of being made.

Registration and hotel Reservation

The meeting registration (due Oct 1) and for poster/presentation abstract submission (due Sep 24) is: https://www.orau.gov/modeling2018/

Those intending to submit abstracts MUST complete both registration and abstract submission by COB, September 24^t^h.

Submit an E3SM poster/presentation

You can submit an abstract of a poster/presentation to the day 1-2 integrated PI Modeling sessions, and/or the E3SM day sessions, there is a limit of at most 2 submissions per person (as fist author): 1 in Integrated session and 1 in E3SM session.

The abstracts for the integrated session have to be submitted through the ORAU website ( https://www.orau.gov/modeling2018/abstracts.htm) and the deadline for those is Monday Sep 24th. When submitting the abstract, in the PI name field - put Dave Bader, and you need to choose you preferred session, which is one of I1, I2, .., I6 (see below). Please submit this abstract to our confluence page as well (E3SM Posters/Presentation in PI Modeling Meeting).

The abstracts for the E3SM session need to be only submitted here (E3SM Posters/Presentation in PI Modeling Meeting), and the deadline is Oct 15th . In the template below, indicate 'E3SM session' in 'Session Type' and choose Session ID as one of: E1, E2, ..., E11 (see below)

Integrated sessions:

I1: Extremes
I2: Land & Land System Dynamics
I3: Tools, Frameworks, and Transitions to Exascale
I4: Coastal Systems
I5: High Latitudes
I6: Data, Metrics, and Diagnostics

E3SM sessions:

E1: E3SM - v2 atmospheric physics
E2: E3SM - Land/energy
E3: E3SM - v3-v4 atmosphere
E4: E3SM - Ocean/cryosphere (v2-v4)
E5: E3SM - Next generation coupled system science
E6: E3SM - Performance (v2)
E7: E3SM - Infrastructure (v2)
E8: E3SM - NGD-computation (v3-v4)
E9: E3SM – v1 results – water cycle
E10: E3SM – v1 results – BGC
E11: E3SM – v1 results – Ocean-cryosphere

Please use E3SM templates when developing poster/presentations – see E3SM Phase 2 Templates, E3SM logos can be found on E3SM Logo and Templates page.

Structure of the Meeting

From Dorothy's email on 20 Aug 2018

Click here for schedule description to expand ...

As mentioned above, the first two days, Nov 5^th and 6^th, will focus on integrative and cross-cutting topics involving Model Development, Model Analysis, and Multisector Dynamics, while the 3^rd and 4^th days (Nov 6^th and Nov 7^th) will be deep-dives into the three respective areas. A high-level draft agenda for the first two days is included as a separate attachment. Major topics and themes spanning all four days are listed below.

DAYS 1-2 Community-Crosscutting

Panel sessions in plenary include:

Extreme-scale computational modeling
Extremes, variability, and change
Integrated water cycle

Parallel breakout sessions include:

Extremes - understanding and modeling single and compound extremes: storms, floods, droughts, heat waves, fire, and other climatologic, hydrologic, land, and socioeconomic disturbances
Coastal systems - understanding and modeling of coastal systems, influences, and transitions - from urban landscapes and infrastructures to managed and unmanaged ecosystems and regional climatologies and local climatological influences and feedbacks
High latitudes - science of coupled high-latitude systems, including feedbacks, interactions and teleconnections with lower latitudes
Land and land-system dynamics - modeling and research of land-use and land-cover change, terrestrial biogeochemistry, vegetation dynamics, and interactions with tightly coupled atmospheric and hydrologic systems and processes
Data, metrics, and diagnostics - accessible and agile community data platforms, distributed data architectures for expanding questions/needs, data analytics and adaptable interfaces, machine learning and pattern recognition, model performance metrics and analysis techniques, and diagnostic methods and applications for evaluating and improving models
Tools, frameworks and transition to exascale - modeling frameworks, modular modeling architectures, advanced software constructs, and supporting tools and infrastructure in transition to exascale computing

Note that scheduled poster sessions on the first and second days of the meeting, aligned with the six themes of the parallel breakout sessions, will complement and enhance the discussions and presentations in the breakouts. Abstracts for presentations, which should align with one of the 6 break-out topics, must be submitted to the meeting website by COB, September 24, 2018.

DAYS 3-4 Community-Specific

The specific agenda for Days 3-4 will be developed in further consultation with the individual communities. As the agendas for each of the communities firm, they will be transmitted in a final form at a later time, along with other facilitating materials and background documents for the week-long meeting. Below are the preliminary topics under consideration for the community-specific meetings.

Earth System Modeling (Model Development)

E3SM overview and coupled simulations

Project overview
Water cycle experiment campaign
BGC experiment campaign
Cryosphere-ocean experiment campaign

E3SM – Next-generation-developments

Version 2 (working version) Atmospheric physics development
Versions3-4 (future version) atmosphere development
Land and energy developments
Next generation coupled system science

E3SM Computation and Infrastructure

Performance (v2)
Infrastructure (v2)
New directions in E3SM computation (v3-v4)

Side session (evening?) E3SM simulation coordination (side meeting between E3SM and leaders of E3SM collaborating projects such as RGMA SFA’s)

Regional and Global Model Analysis (Model Analysis)

RGMA Science Themes

Modes of Variability and Predictability
Water Cycle
Extremes
High Latitude Feedbacks and Interactions
Biogeochemical Feedbacks and Interactions
Cloud-Earth System Feedbacks and Interactions

RGMA Cross-Cutting Themes

Diagnostics, Metrics, and Computational Tools/Approaches to Evaluate and Inform Models
Multi-model approaches and hierarchies for Robust Understanding & Predictability
CMIP6 Analysis
Emulators and Uncertainty characterization
Simulations and computational resources (synergies across RGMA SFAs & projects)

Multisector Dynamics

Hierarchical modeling and emulators – fit for purpose constructs
Coupling methods, software, and advances
Community data platforms
Scenario research and development (integrated water cycle)
Coastal: multisector dynamics, stressors, and transitions
Community leadership, coordination, and working group(s)

The plans for Nov 7-8 (days 3-4) are taking shape. One of those days will focus on E3SM Development and the other day will focus on Model Analysis activities. On the E3SM Development day (see draft agenda below), the priority will be to facilitate discussion among E3SM developers and related E3SM development projects (e.g. SciDAC and other University-led E3SM development projects). We should be able to accommodate many of the related projects with presentations on the E3SM development day, and we will be providing a way to submit abstracts (oral and poster) for those sessions in the coming weeks. If your work fits well within the integrated modeling program agenda (days 1-2, agenda attached) I would encourage you to submit an abstract there, since we probably will not be able to include (oral) presentations by all related E3SM PI’s on the E3SM day. The technical E3SM groups (computing, infrastructure) will meet on the Model Analysis day, since there is little overlap between these communities. It would also be acceptable to submit an abstract to the integrated program (days 1-2 – using the link above) and the E3SM day (instructions to follow) – i.e. up to 2 distinct presentations per person.

November 9 - Day 5 (Friday) will be a half-day of E3SM working-group meetings. Those in the E3SM development community are invited to attend these meetings.

E3SM Development Day Draft Agenda


8:30-8:45	Programmatic updates (Koch)
8:45-9:00	project overview (Bader)
Experimental campaigns
9:00-9:30	water cycle campaign (Golaz)
9:30-10:00	BGC campaign (Calvin)
10:00-10:30	Break
10:30-11:00	Cryosphere campaign (Price)
Community engagement
11:00-11:30	E3SM release (McCoy, Jacob)
E3SM future developments
11:30-12:00	Next generation coupled system science (Leung)
12:00-1:00	Lunch
E3SM future developments - partner projects
1:00-2:30	v2 atmospheric physics Xie (chair) – presentations by related projects
	Land/energy Bond-Lamberty (chair) – presentation by related projects
2:30-3:30	v3-v4 atmosphere Caldwell (chair) – presentations by related projects
	Ocean/cryosphere – Petersen chair – presentation by related projects
3:30-4:00	break
4:00-5:30	Next generation coupled system science Burrows (chair) – presentation by related projects
6:00-6:30	Deep Dives musical performance


Analysis day
30 minutes	Computation overview - Taylor
1 hr (TBD)	Performance (v2) – Jones (chair) – presentation by related projects
1 hr (TBD)	Infrastructure (v2) – Jacob (chair) – presentation by related projects
1 hr (TBD)	NGD-computation (v3-v4) – Salinger (chair) – presentation by related projects
90 minutes (TBD)	E3SM community poster session

Attendee Count and Limitations

All the people signed up on Attendance List to E3SM PI Meeting list have been approved on 19 Sep 2018 . Anyone added after that day and in rows #97 and up, need to check with Dorothy if they can join the meeting before making arrangements for the meeting (which is said to be full).

In case someone from the DOE-Labs who signed up decides NOT to attend, please let Dorothy Koch (Unlicensed) know so she make that space available for any late interest.